Can the small claims court judge postpone a termination to prevent pension losses?

The Future Pensions Act entails a transition to a new pension system for many employees. For some employees, this transition may have adverse consequences. For this reason, a one-time compensation payment is offered in some cases. Whether an employee is eligible for this depends on the terms of the compensation agreements. The date of termination of employment may also play a role. Those who leave employment before the relevant date may miss out on all or part of the compensation. For example, at ABP, the transition to the new pension plan is scheduled for January 1, 2027. To be eligible for compensation, an employee must be accruing pension benefits as of December 31, 2026, and meet the other conditions.

The termination date can therefore not only determine the end of the employment relationship but also have implications for pension benefits. A termination date of, for example, December 1, 2026, rather than January 1, 2027, can therefore suddenly have significant financial consequences.

For this reason, a number of recent termination cases have shown that employees are asking the subdistrict court to set the termination date on or after January 1, 2027. But does such a request stand a chance of success?

The termination date in the case of termination at the employer’s request

First, the legal basis. In the event of termination at the employer’s request, Article 7:671b of the Dutch Civil Code specifies the effective date of such termination. The basic principle is to align with the date on which the employment contract would have ended under normal termination procedures, with the procedural period generally deducted from that date, leaving at least one month remaining. This deduction does not apply if the termination results from serious culpable acts or omissions on the part of the employer. It follows from this statutory provision that, in the event of termination at the employer’s request, the subdistrict court judge has little leeway to extend the termination date as a matter of leniency.

This position is also reflected in a recent ruling by the Rotterdam Subdistrict Court dated October 15, 2026 (ECLI:NL:RBROT:2026:15185). In this case, the judge terminated the employment contract effective December 1, 2026, even though the employee had requested that the termination take effect only after January 1, 2027, due to the transition to a new pension system. The subdistrict court judge ruled that there is no legal basis for postponing the termination date. He noted that there had also been no joint request from the parties, which implies that the subdistrict court judge would have seen room for flexibility if the parties had made a joint request and the employer had therefore agreed to a later termination date.

This is reflected in the decision of the Midden-Nederland Subdistrict Court dated September 2, 2026 (ECLI:NL:RBMNE:2026:6304). During the oral hearing, the subdistrict court judge himself noted that, in the event of an earlier termination, the employee risked losing out on pension compensation announced by ABP. The employer, NZa, subsequently agreed to termination effective January 2, 2027. The subdistrict court judge set the termination date in accordance with that agreement.

Termination at the employee’s request

If the employee files the request for termination, a slightly different legal provision applies to determining the termination date. Article 7:671c of the Dutch Civil Code stipulates that the subdistrict court judge who grants the request determines the date on which the employment contract ends. This wording gives the subdistrict court judge more discretion in determining the termination date than the rules apply in the case of an employer’s request. Of course, the subdistrict court judge is not entirely free to decide. Even in the case of an employee’s request, there must be circumstances that make it equitable for the employment contract to end “immediately or after a short period of time.”

In a recent ruling by the Amsterdam Subdistrict Court dated October 28, 2026, regarding a termination at the employee’s request, the court ruled on a subsequent termination of the employment contract due to the revised pension system (ECLI:NL:RBAMS:2026:10958). In this case, a female employee of the FIOD herself requested the termination of her employment contract. The subdistrict court judge set the termination date as February 1, 2027, partly due to the introduction of the new pension system and to prevent any potential damages resulting from her leaving the organization before January 1, 2027. In doing so, the subdistrict court judge explicitly noted that the FIOD had not objected to that proposed termination date. The fact that the subdistrict court judge explicitly mentioned this indicates that the absence of an objection was significant for the chosen termination date. Whether the judge would have chosen the same date had the FIOD raised an objection is not clear from the ruling.

Conclusion

Based on recent rulings, it can be concluded that the imminent loss of pension benefits does not guarantee that the court will postpone the termination date in termination proceedings. In the case of a request by the employer, the legal leeway is, in principle, limited. In the case of a request by the employee, there appears to be more leeway, but even in the FIOD case, the subdistrict court judge considered it important, at the very least, that the employer not object. The question therefore remains as to what the court would do in this situation if the employer did object to a postponement. It is also not yet clear how long a postponement is possible or whether a joint request is always sufficient for a subdistrict court judge to grant a later termination date. The latter is somewhat reminiscent of the “pro forma” practice, in which the parties jointly requested the judge to dissolve the contract and the judge granted the request in accordance with this joint request.

A settlement agreement offers more flexibility for these types of arrangements. In termination processes, we therefore prefer to address the issue of potential pension compensation early in the negotiations. A later termination date can be part of the overall package of agreements and thus also offer a suitable solution for the employer. After all, the benefit to the employee can be balanced against agreements regarding other termination conditions.

Do you have any questions about this? Please contact us.

Share this article:

Pink piggy bank with white dots and a few coins on a wooden table – retirement compensation upon termination

Experts in this field

Stay informed

Would you like to receive all employment law updates? Sign up for the newsletter.

Related articles

What are you looking for?

Call me back

Please enter your information confidentially to request a callback. This will take about 2 minutes.

For a general legal question you can often find an answer quickly on our website.

Go to the knowledge base →

Briefly describe the situation and explain why legal assistance is needed. Include relevant dates and deadlines. A full explanation is not necessary at this stage.

Download our roadmap

Wage Transparency Act 2027

Enter your email address and receive the roadmap in your mailbox.

Download our white paper

Successful reorganization in practice

Enter your email address to receive the white paper in your mailbox.