A reorganization often involves job eliminations or changes to job roles. This frequently has significant consequences for the employees involved. To mitigate the effects of a reorganization, employers often implement a social plan. But what exactly does a social plan contain, and what rights do employers and employees derive from it?
What is a social plan?
A social plan is an agreement that sets out the terms regarding the consequences of a reorganization or layoffs for employees. This may involve the consequences of redundancies, as well as the impact on the remaining staff.
A social plan is often developed following consultations between the employer and the unions. A social plan can also be agreed upon with the works council, usually within the framework of the works council’s right to be consulted. Sometimes an employer chooses to draw up a social plan on its own, without input from the unions or the works council.
An employer is not legally required to draw up a social plan for every reorganization. However, such an obligation may arise from a collective bargaining agreement or other arrangements. A social plan allows the adverse consequences of a reorganization to be addressed in a uniform manner.
What does a social plan include?
The content of a social plan varies depending on the reorganization. In any case, agreements are often made regarding the following topics:
Termination
The employment contracts of redundant employees who cannot be reassigned will have to be terminated. In many cases, a social plan stipulates that redundant employees will be offered a settlement agreement (VSO). The social plan then specifies the terms and conditions the employer will offer to the affected employees. These can vary widely, but often include:
- the severance pay to be offered (often higher than the statutory transition payment)
- the termination date or notice period
- whether or not vacation days will be paid out
- whether or not there is an exemption from work
- final settlement
- support for transitioning from one job to another, such as outplacement or a training budget
- Reimbursement of legal fees for reviewing the settlement agreement
- What happens to post-contractual provisions, such as a non-compete or non-solicitation clause
The social plan may also include information about what the employer will do if employees do not agree to a settlement agreement (VSO) or do not do so within a certain period.
Selection of Employees
When jobs are eliminated, it must be determined which employees are eligible for termination. Legal rules apply in this regard, including the proportionality principle. This means that employees in interchangeable positions are grouped by age. Next, for each age group, it is determined which employees are eligible for termination. A social plan may also include agreements regarding the application of the proportionality principle, such as provisions for voluntary departure.
Reassignment
The social plan may also include provisions regarding reassignment. After all, an employer must do its best to reassign a redundant employee within the organization before it can proceed with termination. In addition, practical issues are addressed that can be regulated in the social plan. These include how to apply for open positions, what constitutes a suitable position, what happens if multiple employees are eligible for the same position (reverse proportional representation or the “musical chairs” method), whether an employee may accept a settlement agreement even if redeployment is possible, and whether the employee can (voluntarily) claim the right to redeployment during the notice period. Training opportunities related to redeployment may also be included.
Employees Who Will Stay
Sometimes a social plan also includes provisions for employees who will remain with the company. This may be relevant if there are changes to the employees’ job roles or terms of employment. Examples include a relocation, which may result in longer commutes for employees, or an increase, decrease, or change in employees’ responsibilities.
Is a social plan binding?
In principle, a social plan to which the employer has agreed is also binding on the employer. It is also possible that the employer does not personally agree to a social plan but is bound by it under the applicable collective bargaining agreement.
An employee may request that the employer apply the social plan to him or her. However, the employee cannot be compelled to agree to a settlement agreement offered to him or her under the social plan.
What does a social plan mean for employers and employees?
For employers, a social plan provides a framework for implementing a reorganization. By establishing clear agreements in advance, disputes regarding the selection of employees, compensation, and support can be minimized. However, the employer remains responsible for complying with statutory termination rules and any obligations toward the works council.
For employees, a social plan provides clarity regarding the consequences of their position being eliminated and the benefits to which they are entitled. It is important to consider not only the amount of the severance pay but also the other terms and conditions and the implications for, for example, unemployment benefits.
Do you have questions about a social plan or the consequences of a reorganization? Our employment law attorneys are happy to advise employers and employees on their rights and options.