Dismissal of a Director Under the Articles of Incorporation

The termination of a statutory director works differently than the termination of a regular employee. This is because a statutory director has a dual legal status: he or she is both a director under corporate law and an employee with an employment contract. As a result, both corporate law and labor law play a role in the termination process. How exactly does this work, and what do employers and statutory directors need to keep in mind?

How can a statutory director be dismissed?

In principle, a director appointed under the articles of incorporation may be dismissed at any time by the body authorized to appoint him or her. This is usually the General Meeting of Shareholders (GMS), but depending on the articles of incorporation, it may also be another body.

For a dismissal to be legally valid, the proper procedure must be followed. For example, the director must be given timely notice of the meeting at which the dismissal will be discussed. The proposed dismissal must also be included on the agenda, and the director must be given the opportunity to present his or her views and defend himself or herself.

In principle, a legally valid termination decision not only results in the director losing his or her position, but also in the termination of the employment contract. No prior approval from the UWV or the subdistrict court is required for this. This is an important difference from the dismissal of an ordinary employee, where a preventive review by the UWV or the subdistrict court is required.

What grounds can lead to termination?

In principle, the General Meeting of Shareholders may dismiss a statutory director at any time and for any reason. However, not every reason constitutes just cause for dismissal under employment law. This is because, even for a statutory director, there must be reasonable grounds for dismissal. If there is no reasonable cause but a legally valid termination decision, the employment contract still terminates, but the statutory director may be entitled to fair compensation.

Examples of possible grounds for termination include business conditions, a strained working relationship, poor performance, or culpable conduct. Long-term incapacity to work may also, under certain conditions, constitute grounds for termination. In addition, a difference of opinion regarding the company’s policy or strategy may play a role.

When assessing the grounds for termination, the court takes into account the special position of a statutory director. Because of the responsibility and trust associated with the position, a difference of opinion or a strained relationship is more likely to lead to termination than it would for an ordinary employee.

What protection against dismissal does a statutory director have?

A statutory director has less protection against dismissal than an ordinary employee. For example, there is no preliminary review by the UWV or the subdistrict court. Furthermore, after a legally valid dismissal, the director cannot request reinstatement of the employment contract, even if there were no reasonable grounds for dismissal.

However, any prohibition on termination must be taken into account. This may apply, for example, if the director is ill. If the director is already on sick leave at the time he is summoned to the meeting at which his dismissal is to be discussed, the prohibition on termination during sick leave may prevent the employment contract from being terminated as well. In that case, the director may lose his position, while the employment contract remains in effect.

At the end of the two-year period of incapacity for work, the prohibition on termination generally expires. However, it must be assessed whether the employer has fulfilled its reintegration obligations and whether there are any other obstacles to termination.

Is a statutory director entitled to compensation?

Upon termination of the employment contract, the statutory director is, in principle, entitled to a statutory transition payment. In addition, the employment contract or a separate agreement may entitle the director to a supplementary severance payment that was agreed upon in advance. This payment is also referred to as a “golden parachute.”

If there is no reasonable ground for termination or if the employer has acted in a seriously culpable manner, the director may, under certain circumstances, also be entitled to equitable compensation. The court may award this compensation, but cannot reinstate the employment contract.

A statutory director may also be dismissed with immediate effect if there is a compelling reason and the other legal conditions are met. In that case, the employment contract terminates immediately, and, in principle, there is no entitlement to a transition payment.

Settlement Agreement and Discharge

In practice, the terms regarding the departure of a statutory director are often set forth in a settlement agreement (VSO). In this agreement, the parties can agree on the termination date, compensation, any exemption from work, and other conditions for the termination.

The issue of discharge may also arise when a director leaves the company. Through discharge, the company, in principle, grants the director a release from liability for the management of the company, to the extent that the relevant information was known to the shareholders or was apparent from the financial statements. Discharge is not an automatic consequence of resignation and must be granted separately. Furthermore, discharge does not protect the director from claims by third parties.

What does this mean for employers and directors?

The termination of a statutory director requires a careful approach. It is important for employers not only to correctly follow the procedures under corporate law but also to take into account the implications under labor law, such as the grounds for termination, any prohibitions on termination, and severance payments.

It is important for directors to know that a decision to dismiss them does not automatically mean that all financial entitlements are forfeited. Even if the dismissal as a director is legally valid, disputes may arise regarding the termination of the employment contract and the amount of severance pay.

Do you have questions about the termination of a statutory director or a potential dispute with a director or company? Our employment law attorneys are happy to advise employers and employees on their rights and options.

Share this article:

A man in a suit leaves an office building with his coat over his arm – dismissal of a statutory director

Experts in this field

Stay informed

Would you like to receive all employment law updates? Sign up for the newsletter.

Related articles

What are you looking for?

Call me back

Fill in your details and we will call you back as soon as possible.

Download our roadmap

Wage Transparency Act 2027

Enter your email address and receive the roadmap in your mailbox.

Download our white paper

Successful reorganization in practice

Enter your email address to receive the white paper in your mailbox.